TYBMS SEM 5 Logistics & Supply Chain Management (November 2024 Question Paper with Solution)

 Paper/Subject Code: 46001/Logistics & Supply Chain Management

TYBMS SEM 5

Logistics & Supply Chain Management

(November 2024 Question Paper with Solution)


Course: TYBMS

Semester : V

Subject : Logistics & Supply Chain Management

University : University of Mumbai

Exam : November 2024


Introduction

This article provides the TYBMS Semester 5 Logistics & Supply Chain Management question paper for the November 2024 examination along with detailed solutions. The solutions are explained step-by-step to help students understand the method used to solve each problem and prepare for their university examination.


Note:

1) All Questions are compulsory with internal choice options and carry 15 marks each.

2) Figures to the right indicate full marks

3) Use of simple Calculator is allowed

4) Working note should form part of your answer for practical questions.



Q.1) A) Choose the correct option (Any 8):                (08)

1) _________ Logistics is the decision to buy logistics services from external sources rather than operate in house.

(a) Reverse,

(b) Green,

(c) Outsourcing.

(d) Standard


2) The main objective of __________ is to reduce the number of times the product is handled.

(a) Packaging.

(b) Transportation,

(c) Material Handling.

(d) Warehousing


3) Combining several shipments into one large shipment is termed as ________. 

(a) Sorting.

(b) Assortment,

(c) Consolidation.

(d) Cross Docking


4) COFC stands for _________ on Flat car.

(a) Carton,

(b) Carrier.

(c) Container,

(d) Crane


5) The primary goal of the _________ logistics cycle is to move products or materials backward through the distribution network.

(a) Green,

(b) Reverse.

(c) Inbound,

(d) Outbound


6) ________ is not an objective of performance measurement.

(a) Planning,

(b) Monitoring.

(c) Controlling.

(d) Directing


7) Basic requirements of Logistics parks are Land and area, ________ availability. and Human resource

(a) Plant

(b) Warehouse

(c) I.T.

(d) Connectivity


8) _________ type of material handling equipment does not require an operator.

(a) Fork Lift truck,

(b) Crane,

(c) Industrial Trucks,

(d) Conveyors


9) Transportation creates ________ utility

(a) Product

(b) Economic

(c) Time

(d) Place


10) Lack of communication between members of supply chain leads to ________ effect.

(a) Miscommunication,

(b) Bull- Whip,

(c) Classical,

(d) Bad


Q.1) B) Match the Following (Any 7)            (07)

Column A

Column B

1) Deep water ports

(a) External Performance Measure

2) Top down approach

(b) Decentralization

3) Bottom-up approach

(c) Elevator

4) 3PL

(d) Freight Trains

5) 4PL

(e) Owns Logistical Infrastructure

6) Benchmarking

(f) Paints

7) Tinplate

(g) Centralization

8) D.F.C

(h) Planning and Designing activities

9) Fixed path M.H. equipment

(i) Cranes

10) Variable M.H. equipment

(j) Fully loaded ship

Ans:

Column A

Column B

1) Deep water ports

(j) Fully loaded ship 

2) Top down approach

(g) Centralization

3) Bottom-up approach

(b) Decentralization 

4) 3PL

(e) Owns Logistical Infrastructure 

5) 4PL

(h) Planning and Designing activities

6) Benchmarking

(a) External Performance Measure

7) Tinplate

(f) Paints

8) D.F.C

(d) Freight Trains

9) Fixed path M.H. equipment

(c) Elevator

10) Variable M.H. equipment

(i) Cranes


Q.2) a) Explain the concept of Logistical Information System (LIS). Explain the Principles and types of LIS.                                        (08)

A Logistical Information System (LIS) is a specialized system designed to manage, track, and optimize the flow of goods, services, and information across the supply chain. It integrates various logistics functions, including transportation, inventory management, warehousing, and order processing, ensuring smooth operations and better decision-making.

LIS provides real-time data, analytical insights, and automation to improve efficiency, reduce costs, and enhance customer satisfaction. It acts as a bridge between physical flow (goods movement) and information flow (data tracking and reporting) across all supply chain stages.

Objectives of LIS:

  • Optimize supply chain efficiency by tracking and managing logistics operations.
  • Enhance decision-making with real-time, data-driven insights.
  • Reduce operational costs through better inventory and transportation planning.
  • Improve customer service by ensuring timely and accurate deliveries.
  • Ensure information flow across various stakeholders in the supply chain.

Principles of Logistical Information System:

1.     Accuracy and Timeliness:

o    Data within the system must be accurate and up-to-date to ensure effective decision-making.

2.     Integration:

o    The LIS should integrate all logistics activities (transportation, inventory, order processing) with other business functions like marketing and finance.

3.     Accessibility:

o    Information should be easily accessible to authorized personnel across the supply chain.

4.     Flexibility and Scalability:

o    The system must be flexible to adapt to changing business needs and scalable to accommodate growth.

5.     Cost-effectiveness:

o    The LIS should improve logistics efficiency while maintaining low operational costs.

6.     Security and Confidentiality:

o    Sensitive logistics data must be protected from unauthorized access.

7.     User-Friendliness:

o    The system should have an intuitive interface for ease of use and training.

Types of Logistical Information Systems:

1.     Planning and Coordination Systems:

o    Focus on forecasting, demand planning, and resource allocation.

o    Examples: Inventory Management Systems, Demand Forecasting Tools.

2.     Execution Systems:

o    Manage the day-to-day operational processes.

o    Examples: Warehouse Management System (WMS), Transportation Management System (TMS).

3.     Monitoring and Reporting Systems:

o    Provide real-time tracking, report generation, and performance analysis.

o    Examples: Shipment Tracking, Performance Dashboards.

4.     Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) Systems:

o    Integrate logistics with other business functions like accounting and procurement.

o    Examples: SAP ERP, Oracle NetSuite.

5.     Decision Support Systems (DSS):

o    Assist in strategic decision-making using advanced analytics.

o    Examples: Route Optimization Tools, Simulation Models.

 

b) What do you mean by Packaging? Explain various functions of packaging. (07)

Meaning AND Definition of Packaging

Packaging is a process of preparing goods for safe, secure, convenient handling, transport, distribution, storage, selling, consumption, reuse or disposal of waste. With the development of packaging logistics concept, the definition and scope of packaging have also been enlarged and many other allied and inter-related services have been added to the definition of packaging. Logistical packaging is defined as:

1. "Logistical packaging is the science, art and technology of ensuring safety and protecting product against spoilage, preserving the original qualities of the product for distribution, storage, sale and use. It also refers to process of designing, evaluating utility and production of packages."

2. "Packaging logistics uses a system approach to examine all the essential roles of packaging in supply chain, from the purchase of raw materials to production to sale of goods, as well as transport and distribution."

Functions/Benefits of Packaging

The following are the important functions of packaging.

1. Product Identification:

Packaging serves as a means to distinguish or identify the product in an already crowded market. Unique design Packaging size, shape, coloured container, etc. are used to make the product unique, noticeable and different in the competitive market. For example, Maggi 2 Minutes Noodles. It's rectangular shape, yellow colour and picture of bowl full of ready to eat noodles makes it attractive and unique in its category.

2. Product Protection:

The main function of packaging is to protect product against temperature fluctuation (ice cream), vibration (TV). protection against fungus (for camera lens), spoilage (milk and vegetables), dirt, insects, breakage, etc.

3. Kissan Pizza and Convenience:

Packaging should be simple and easy to handle and transport from one place to another. For example, Kiss Pasta Sauce is available in bottle shaped plastic handy pouch which is easy to carry mainly in travelling. Packaging should enable retailers to store, display and sale goods without much difficulty.

4. Communication:

This is an important function of logistical packaging.

This function is very important for cargo identification and tracking facility. Package contains information about manufacturer, product, type of container, Universal Product Code (UPC). The information is very useful to identify product for receiving order, picking, etc. Package also provides special handling instructions like side up, handle with care, hazardous chemicals, glassware, temperature instructions, storage considerations, etc.

5. Tracking:

This facility enables to track the flow of goods from receiving, storing, retrieved and transported. This is an efficient and effective system of controlling pilferage, theft and monitoring material flow.

6. Logistical and Other Functions:

Packaging functions can be further classified as under:

(a) Environmental Functions:

Relates to reverse logistics, recycling, disposal of waste, use of eco-friendly and biodegradable packing materials.

(b) Logistical Functions:

To ensure safety and security of product, easy of storing and handling, use of automation and technology in packaging logistics.

(c) Unitization:

It is a process of consolidation of several units into one single unit to reduce material handling cost and ensure easy handling.

(d) Protection during transport and ease of transport.

(e) Display the original package for point of purchase advertising.

7. of Packaging Cost:

Efficient logistics packaging helps in minimising losses in transit, improves the operating efficiency of material handling, transportation and better use of space utility. This result in remarkable reduction in packaging cost.

8. Apportionment:

To apportion means to divide and share. On the basis of quantity/volume of buying, packaging should be designed to meet the consumer requirements. For example, floor cleaners for industrial buyers and hospitals is available in cans of 5 litres whereas for home users it is available in 500 ml or 1000 ml bottles.

9. Containment:

Product package should provide adequate space to pack pre-determined volume. For example, for packing 500 ml milk, the correct size of pouch should allow adequate space plus some space for sealing. Packing 500 ml milk in 1 litre pouch is not advisable.

10. Other Functions:

The other functions of packaging include promotion, information, easy handling, trouble-free transportation.

 

OR

 

c) From the following data calculate a 3 period weighted moving average with weights as 3, 2 and 1. The largest weight is assigned to most recent period and current demand value. Also forecast the demand for 9th month.                    (10)

Period (Month)

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

Demand in Units

150

160

180

190

140

120

170

175

?

 

Ans:

Period

(Month)

Demand in Units

3 Period Moving

3 Period

Moving Average

1

150

-

-

2

160

-

-

3

180

-

-

4

190

 

 

5

140

 

 

6

120

 

 

7

170

 

 

8

175

 

 

9

?

 

 

 

d) Explain the objectives of Logistical Network analysis.            (05)

Ans:

Logistical Network Analysis refers to the systematic examination and evaluation of the entire supply chain network, including warehouses, distribution centers, transportation routes, and inventory locations. The primary goal is to design an efficient, cost-effective, and responsive logistics system that meets customer demands while optimizing resources.

The Prime Objectives of Logistical Network Analysis:

1.     Cost Optimization:

o    Minimize transportation, warehousing, inventory, and operational costs.

o    Identify the most economical routes and strategic facility locations to reduce freight expenses and stock holding costs.

2.     Service Level Improvement:

o    Enhance customer satisfaction by improving delivery speed, accuracy, and order fulfillment.

o    Ensure products are delivered on time and in optimal condition through better network design.

3.     Inventory Management:

o    Optimize inventory levels across the supply chain to reduce overstocking and stockouts.

o    Ensure a balanced flow of goods by aligning supply with demand forecasts.

4.     Facility Location and Design:

o    Identify the optimal locations for warehouses, distribution centers, and manufacturing facilities.

o    Improve the geographical positioning to reduce delivery times and enhance market coverage.

5.     Efficiency in Transportation:

o    Evaluate and choose the most effective modes of transportation (road, rail, air, sea).

o    Optimize shipment consolidation and route planning to minimize delays and reduce carbon footprint.

6.     Scalability and Flexibility:

o    Design a scalable logistics network that adapts to market changes, seasonal demand, and business growth.

o    Ensure the network is flexible enough to manage unexpected disruptions like supply chain shocks.

7.     Risk Mitigation:

o    Identify potential bottlenecks, supply chain vulnerabilities, and disruption risks.

o    Develop contingency plans and alternative routes to maintain supply chain continuity.

8.     Technology Integration:

o    Leverage data analytics, IoT, AI, and automation to enhance visibility and decision-making.

o    Implement Logistical Information Systems (LIS) for real-time tracking and performance analysis.

9.     Sustainability and Environmental Compliance:

o    Optimize the network to reduce fuel consumption, emissions, and waste.

o    Adopt eco-friendly practices like green logistics and reverse logistics.

10. Strategic Decision Support:

  • Provide data-driven insights to guide strategic and tactical business decisions.
  • Support decisions regarding outsourcing, partnerships, and infrastructure investments.

Importance of Logistical Network Analysis:

  • Reduces operational inefficiencies and cost leakages.
  • Ensures agility in responding to customer needs and market shifts.
  • Facilitates long-term planning and competitive advantage.

 

Q.3) 

a) Explain the concept of Supply Chain Management with the help of its any 3 functions and any 3 participants in the supply-chain network.   (08)

Supply Chain Management (SCM) refers to the planning, coordination, and control of the entire flow of goods, services, information, and finances—from raw material procurement to the delivery of the final product to the end customer. It involves managing the interconnected processes across suppliers, manufacturers, distributors, retailers, and customers to ensure efficiency, cost optimization, and customer satisfaction.

SCM integrates key business functions to enhance operational efficiency, minimize costs, and deliver value to customers while maintaining competitive advantage.

Functions of Supply Chain Management:

1.     Procurement (Sourcing & Purchasing):

o    Involves sourcing raw materials, components, and services from suppliers.

o    Ensures cost-effective and timely acquisition while maintaining quality standards.

o    Example: A smartphone manufacturer sourcing microchips from global suppliers.

2.     Inventory Management:

o    Optimizes the levels of raw materials, work-in-progress, and finished goods.

o    Ensures availability of products while minimizing carrying costs and avoiding stockouts.

o    Example: Retailers use advanced inventory tracking systems to maintain optimal stock levels.

3.     Logistics & Distribution:

o    Manages the transportation, warehousing, and delivery of products.

o    Ensures efficient movement of goods from suppliers to customers.

o    Example: An e-commerce company uses third-party logistics (3PL) to deliver orders.

Participants in the Supply Chain Network:

1.     Suppliers:

o    Provide raw materials, components, and essential inputs to manufacturers.

o    Ensure consistent quality, timely delivery, and cost efficiency.

o    Example: A steel manufacturer supplying materials to an automotive company.

2.     Manufacturers/Producers:

o    Convert raw materials into finished products through production processes.

o    Focus on quality control, efficiency, and innovation in production.

o    Example: A car manufacturer producing vehicles for global markets.

3.     Distributors/Retailers:

o    Facilitate the storage, marketing, and sale of products to end consumers.

o    Ensure products are accessible and delivered through appropriate channels.

o    Example: Supermarkets or online retailers like Amazon and Walmart.

Why is SCM Important?

  • Reduces costs through optimized processes and inventory.
  • Improves customer satisfaction with faster, accurate deliveries.
  • Enhances collaboration among supply chain participants.

 

b) What do you mean by a warehouse? Explain warehousing functions with reference to storage of production support items.          (07)

A warehouse is a physical facility used for storing goods, materials, and products before they are distributed for sale or use. It serves as a crucial part of the supply chain, providing a central location to receive, store, and dispatch goods efficiently. Warehouses play a key role in maintaining a steady supply of raw materials and finished goods to meet market demand.

When it comes to production support items, a warehouse stores materials that are essential for the manufacturing process, such as raw materials, components, spare parts, and tools. This ensures a continuous flow of inputs to production lines and minimizes downtime.

Functions of Warehousing (with Reference to Production Support Items):

1.     Receiving and Inspection:

o    Function: Accepts production materials from suppliers, verifies the quantity and quality, and inspects for any defects.

o    Example: A warehouse receives batches of steel sheets for an automobile plant and checks their dimensions and quality before storage.

2.     Storage and Preservation:

o    Function: Stores raw materials, semi-finished goods, and spare parts in appropriate conditions to prevent damage and maintain product integrity.

o    Example: Temperature-controlled sections for storing chemicals or sensitive electronics required in production.

3.     Inventory Management:

o    Function: Tracks and controls stock levels of production support items to ensure materials are available when needed while avoiding overstocking or stockouts.

o    Example: Using inventory management systems (IMS) to monitor the quantity of bearings and machine parts in real time.

4.     Order Picking and Material Dispatch:

o    Function: Selects and dispatches production materials to manufacturing lines based on work orders and production schedules.

o    Example: Sending packaging materials and lubricants from the warehouse to a production line when required.

5.     Material Handling:

o    Function: Uses equipment like forklifts, conveyors, and cranes to move and organize bulk items efficiently within the warehouse.

o    Example: Moving heavy metal sheets from receiving docks to designated storage areas.

6.     Quality Control and Compliance:

o    Function: Ensures stored items meet quality standards and comply with safety regulations. Regular audits help maintain product traceability.

o    Example: Checking that electrical components comply with ISO safety standards before issuing them to the production line.

7.     Packaging and Labeling:

o    Function: Packages and labels production items for easy identification, safe handling, and damage prevention during storage and movement.

o    Example: Labeling machinery parts with barcodes to speed up tracking and reordering processes.

8.     Just-in-Time (JIT) Delivery Support:

o    Function: Facilitates JIT inventory by delivering production items on-demand, reducing the need for on-site storage at the manufacturing facility.

o    Example: Delivering engine parts to an assembly line only when production requires them.

Why Warehousing is Essential for Production Support:

  • Continuity of Operations: Ensures uninterrupted production by providing timely access to critical materials.
  • Efficiency: Streamlines material flow and reduces manufacturing delays.
  • Cost Savings: Minimizes waste, overstocking, and emergency procurement costs.
  • Inventory Accuracy: Enhances traceability and forecasting through advanced warehouse management systems (WMS).

 

OR

 

c) Discuss the concept of Performance measurement in supply chain, also explain dimensions/types of internal performance measures.   (08)

Performance measurement in supply chain refers to the process of tracking, analyzing, and evaluating the efficiency and effectiveness of various supply chain activities. It involves using quantitative and qualitative metrics to assess how well a supply chain meets operational goals, customer expectations, and business objectives.

Effective performance measurement helps organizations:

  • Identify bottlenecks and inefficiencies
  • Optimize costs and resources
  • Improve customer satisfaction
  • Enhance decision-making through data-driven insights

Objectives of Supply Chain Performance Measurement:

1.     Efficiency Improvement – Minimize costs while optimizing operations.

2.     Customer Satisfaction – Ensure timely and accurate delivery of products.

3.     Inventory Optimization – Balance inventory levels to reduce excess stock and avoid shortages.

4.     Operational Visibility – Provide real-time insights into supply chain performance.

5.     Continuous Improvement – Identify areas for ongoing refinement and innovation.

Dimensions/Types of Internal Performance Measures in Supply Chain

Internal performance measures focus on in-house processes and activities within the supply chain. They track how well an organization manages its internal operations to deliver products and services efficiently.

Dimensions/types of internal performance measures:

1. Cost Performance Measures

  • Evaluate the financial efficiency of supply chain activities.
  • Key Metrics:
    • Total Supply Chain Cost (TSC) – Sum of all expenses related to supply chain operations.
    • Cost per Order – Average cost to process and fulfill each customer order.
    • Inventory Carrying Cost – Cost of holding inventory, including storage, insurance, and depreciation.
    • Transportation Cost – Expense related to moving products across the supply chain.

Example: Monitoring production costs to identify opportunities for cost reduction without compromising quality.

2. Time/Responsiveness Performance Measures

  • Measure the speed and agility of supply chain operations.
  • Key Metrics:
    • Order Fulfilment Cycle Time – Total time from receiving a customer order to delivery.
    • Lead Time – Time taken to procure, produce, and deliver goods.
    • Inventory Turnover Rate – Frequency of inventory sold and replaced during a specific period.
    • On-Time Delivery (OTD) – Percentage of orders delivered by the promised date.

Example: Reducing lead times by adopting just-in-time (JIT) practices.

3. Quality Performance Measures

  • Assess the accuracy and reliability of products and processes.
  • Key Metrics:
    • Order Accuracy Rate – Percentage of error-free orders delivered to customers.
    • Return Rate – Number of products returned due to defects or incorrect deliveries.
    • First Pass Yield (FPY) – Percentage of products meeting quality standards without rework.
    • Supplier Quality Rating – Evaluation of supplier performance based on defect rates and adherence to specifications.

Example: Implementing quality checks to reduce defective items on the production line.

4. Flexibility Performance Measures

  • Reflect the ability to adapt to changes in demand or market conditions.
  • Key Metrics:
    • Production Flexibility – Ability to adjust production volume or switch product types quickly.
    • Supply Chain Agility – Responsiveness to unexpected disruptions or market shifts.
    • Changeover Time – Time taken to switch from producing one product to another.

Example: Increasing flexibility by using modular manufacturing systems to adapt to customized orders.

5. Asset Utilization Performance Measures

  • Monitor how effectively supply chain assets (e.g., facilities, equipment) are used.
  • Key Metrics:
    • Capacity Utilization Rate – Percentage of production capacity currently in use.
    • Warehouse Space Utilization – Efficiency in using storage facilities.
    • Return on Assets (ROA) – Profitability generated relative to total assets invested.

Example: Optimizing warehouse layouts to improve space utilization and minimize material handling time.

6. Innovation and Learning Performance Measures

  • Focus on continuous improvement and process innovation within the supply chain.
  • Key Metrics:
    • R&D Spend Ratio – Investment in research and development as a percentage of revenue.
    • New Product Introduction (NPI) Cycle Time – Time taken to bring new products to market.
    • Process Improvement Rate – Rate at which operational processes are optimized.

Example: Implementing automated tracking systems to enhance supply chain visibility.

Importance of Internal Performance Measurement in Supply Chain:

  • Operational Efficiency – Reduces waste and enhances productivity.
  • Customer-Centric Approach – Improves service levels and delivery accuracy.
  • Data-Driven Decisions – Supports better forecasting and planning.
  • Competitive Advantage – Strengthens market position through innovation and responsiveness.

 

d) What are different Global Logistics trends? Justify with examples.           (07)

In the rapidly evolving landscape of global logistics, various trends are shaping the way goods are transported, stored, and delivered.

1. Digital Transformation

The integration of digital technologies into logistics operations is a major trend. Companies are leveraging technologies such as the Internet of Things (IoT), artificial intelligence (AI), and big data analytics to enhance efficiency and visibility.

Example: Amazon uses AI algorithms to optimize its supply chain, predicting demand and managing inventory levels. This allows for faster delivery times and reduced operational costs.

2. Sustainability and Green Logistics

With increasing awareness of environmental issues, companies are adopting sustainable practices in logistics. This includes using eco-friendly packaging, optimizing transportation routes, and investing in electric vehicles.

Example: Unilever has committed to reducing its carbon footprint by using renewable energy sources in its logistics operations and optimizing its supply chain to minimize waste.

3. E-commerce Growth

The rise of e-commerce has transformed logistics, necessitating faster and more flexible delivery options. Companies are adapting their logistics strategies to meet the demands of online shoppers.

Example: Companies like Shopify are providing logistics solutions that integrate with e-commerce platforms, enabling businesses to manage inventory and fulfil orders efficiently.

4. Automation and Robotics

Automation is becoming increasingly prevalent in warehouses and distribution centres. Robotics and automated systems are being used to streamline operations, reduce labour costs, and improve accuracy.

Example: Ocado, a UK-based online grocery retailer, employs robotic systems in its warehouses to pick and pack orders, significantly increasing efficiency and reducing human error.

5. Last-Mile Delivery Innovations

The last mile of delivery is often the most challenging and costly part of the logistics process. Companies are exploring innovative solutions to enhance last-mile delivery efficiency.

Example: Companies like DoorDash and Uber Eats have developed advanced logistics platforms that utilize gig economy workers for rapid last-mile delivery, allowing for greater flexibility and speed.

6. Blockchain Technology

Blockchain technology is being explored for its potential to enhance transparency and security in supply chains. It allows for real-time tracking of goods and verification of transactions.

Example: IBM and Maersk have collaborated on a blockchain platform called Trade Lens, which enables stakeholders to share shipping data securely and transparently, reducing delays and improving efficiency.

7. Resilience and Risk Management

The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted the importance of resilience in logistics. Companies are now focusing on risk management strategies to prepare for disruptions in the supply chain.

Example: Companies like Procter & Gamble have diversified their supplier base and increased inventory levels to mitigate risks associated with supply chain disruptions.

8. Global Trade Dynamics

Changes in global trade policies and tariffs are influencing logistics strategies. Companies must adapt to shifting regulations and trade agreements to maintain competitiveness.

Example: The US-China trade war prompted many companies to reevaluate their supply chains, with some relocating manufacturing to countries with more favorable trade conditions.

9. Omnichannel Logistics

The integration of multiple sales channels is becoming essential for retailers. Omnichannel logistics allows companies to provide a seamless shopping experience across online and offline platforms.

Example: Walmart has implemented an omnichannel strategy that enables customers to order online and pick up in-store, enhancing convenience and reducing delivery times.

10. Workforce Development and Training

As logistics becomes more technologically advanced, there is a growing need for skilled workers. Companies are investing in workforce development and training programs to equip employees with the necessary skills.

Example: DHL has launched various training initiatives to upskill its workforce in areas such as data analytics and automation, ensuring that employees are prepared for the future of logistics.

 

Q.4)

a) I.T. plays a very important role in Logistics and Supply chain management. Justify the statement with the help of any four I.T. Infrastructure tools used in Logistics and Supply chain.                 (08)

Information Technology (I.T.) plays a crucial role in enhancing the efficiency, transparency, and accuracy of logistics and supply chain management (SCM). It enables real-time data sharing, faster decision-making, and seamless coordination across various supply chain activities such as inventory management, order processing, transportation, and customer service.

By leveraging I.T. infrastructure tools, businesses can reduce costs, minimize errors, and improve customer satisfaction.

Four Key I.T. Infrastructure Tools in Logistics and SCM

1. Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) Systems

What is it?
An ERP system integrates core business functions (such as inventory, procurement, production, and logistics) into one centralized platform, providing real-time visibility across the supply chain.

Example:

  • SAP S/4HANA and Oracle NetSuite are popular ERP systems used by companies like Unilever and PepsiCo to manage global supply chains.

Justification:

  • Centralized Data Management: Ensures real-time information sharing across departments.
  • Inventory Optimization: Tracks stock levels and reduces overstocking or shortages.
  • Order Accuracy: Reduces errors in order processing and enhances delivery efficiency.

2. Warehouse Management System (WMS)

What is it?
A Warehouse Management System automates and optimizes warehouse operations such as receiving, picking, packing, and shipping.

Example:

  • Amazon uses advanced WMS integrated with robotic automation to process millions of orders efficiently.
  • Manhattan Associates and Blue Yonder offer WMS solutions for complex supply chains.

Justification:

  • Improved Accuracy: Reduces picking and shipping errors through barcode scanning and automation.
  • Space Optimization: Maximizes warehouse space through intelligent slotting algorithms.
  • Faster Order Fulfillment: Increases efficiency by optimizing the flow of goods within the warehouse.

3. Transportation Management System (TMS)

What is it?
A TMS is a software solution that helps businesses plan, execute, and optimize the physical movement of goods across different transportation modes (road, rail, air, and sea).

Example:

  • FedEx and DHL use TMS for route optimization and real-time shipment tracking.
  • Solutions like SAP TM and Oracle Transportation Management assist in global logistics operations.

Justification:

  • Route Optimization: Reduces fuel costs by finding the most efficient delivery routes.
  • Real-Time Tracking: Provides customers with accurate delivery timelines.
  • Compliance Management: Ensures adherence to international regulations and tariffs.

4. Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) & Internet of Things (IoT)

What is it?
RFID and IoT technologies allow for real-time tracking and monitoring of physical assets through connected devices and sensors.

Example:

  • Walmart uses RFID tags to track products across its supply chain, ensuring better inventory visibility.
  • Maersk uses IoT sensors to monitor the temperature and condition of perishable goods during transit.

Justification:

  • Real-Time Monitoring: Tracks product location and condition across the supply chain.
  • Loss Prevention: Reduces theft and misplacement by providing accurate asset tracking.
  • Data Insights: Improves predictive analytics and demand forecasting through real-time data collection.

Why I.T. is Essential in Modern Logistics and SCM:

1.     Enhanced Visibility: Real-time monitoring improves transparency across supply chain stages.

2.     Operational Efficiency: Automation reduces manual tasks, saving time and resources.

3.     Better Decision-Making: Data-driven insights enable accurate forecasting and planning.

4.     Customer Satisfaction: Faster delivery and real-time tracking enhance the customer experience.

 

b) Explain in detail role of Pipeline and Ropeways mode of transportation in building a sustainable economy.                                    (07)

Sustainable transportation plays a vital role in fostering economic growth while minimizing environmental impacts. Pipelines and ropeways are two key modes of transportation that contribute to a sustainable economy through energy efficiency, reduced emissions, and low operational costs.

1. Role of Pipelines in Building a Sustainable Economy

Pipelines are used to transport liquids, gases, and semi-solid materials (e.g., oil, natural gas, water, chemicals) over long distances through a system of underground or above-ground pipes.

How Pipelines Contribute to a Sustainable Economy:

1.     Energy Efficiency & Reduced Carbon Footprint:

o    Pipelines are the most energy-efficient mode for transporting liquids and gases compared to road or rail.

o    Example: Transporting natural gas via pipelines uses 5 times less energy than by trucks, reducing greenhouse gas emissions significantly.

2.     Reduced Traffic Congestion & Road Accidents:

o    By moving bulk commodities underground, pipelines reduce the need for heavy truck traffic on roads.

o    Example: In the USA, pipelines transport about 70% of crude oil, reducing road wear and traffic congestion.

3.     Lower Operational Costs & Long-Term Sustainability:

o    Pipelines have low maintenance costs and provide a continuous flow of resources.

o    Example: India’s HVJ (Hazira-Vijaipur-Jagdishpur) Gas Pipeline facilitates low-cost natural gas distribution across regions, boosting industrial growth sustainably.

4.     Environmental Safety & Reduced Spills:

o    Modern pipelines are equipped with smart monitoring and leak detection systems to minimize environmental damage.

o    Example: Trans-Alaska Pipeline uses advanced monitoring to prevent oil spills and protect local ecosystems.

2. Role of Ropeways in Building a Sustainable Economy

Ropeways (cable cars or aerial lifts) are a cable-based transport system used for carrying people or cargo across difficult terrains (mountains, rivers, urban areas).

How Ropeways Contribute to a Sustainable Economy:

1.     Eco-Friendly Transportation with Low Emissions:

o    Ropeways consume less energy and produce fewer emissions than traditional vehicles.

o    Example: Gulmarg Gondola in India promotes sustainable tourism while reducing vehicle pollution in sensitive mountain areas.

2.     Cost-Effective for Difficult Terrain:

o    Ropeways offer low infrastructure costs and quick installation in areas where building roads is economically or environmentally impractical.

o    Example: Aerial cargo ropeways in South America transport agricultural goods across mountainous regions efficiently.

3.     Reducing Urban Traffic & Pollution:

o    Ropeways can ease urban traffic congestion by providing an alternative transport mode.

o    Example: Medellín Metro cable (Colombia) provides low-emission public transport, reducing road congestion and CO₂ output.

4.     Promotes Tourism & Local Economy:

o    Ropeways enable sustainable tourism by offering eco-friendly transport to remote scenic areas.

o    Example: Auli Ropeway in India attracts tourists while preserving the fragile Himalayan ecosystem.

 

OR

 

c) Write a detailed Note on Reorder Level and calculate the sum on ROL. Daily consumption of raw material in the production process is 300 units. Lead time for delivery is 5 days. Company's policy is to keep safety stock equal to six days daily consumption. Calculate ROL.                (10)

Reorder Level (ROL) is the inventory level at which a company must place a new order to replenish its stock before it runs out. It ensures that there is sufficient stock available to continue operations smoothly during the lead time (the time taken for new inventory to arrive).

Maintaining the correct ROL helps in:

1.     Preventing Stockouts: Ensures uninterrupted production or sales.

2.     Optimizing Inventory: Balances overstocking and understocking.

3.     Reducing Holding Costs: Minimizes excessive inventory storage costs.

4.     Ensuring Smooth Operations: Provides a buffer against uncertainties like supplier delays.

Formula for Reorder Level (ROL)

ROL= (Daily Consumption × Lead Time) + Safety Stock

Where:

  • Daily Consumption = Units consumed per day
  • Lead Time = Time taken by the supplier to deliver new stock (in days)
  • Safety Stock = Extra inventory kept to handle unexpected demand or delays

Calculation of ROL – Given Data:

  • Daily Consumption = 300 units/day
  • Lead Time = 5 days
  • Safety Stock = 6 days of daily consumption

Step 1: Calculate Safety Stock

Safety Stock=Daily Consumption × Safety Days

Safety Stock=300×6=1800 units

Step 2: Calculate ROL

ROL = (Daily Consumption × Lead Time) + Safety Stock

ROL = (300×5) + 1800

ROL=1500+1800=3300 units

The Reorder Level (ROL) is 3,300 units.
This means the company should place a new order when the inventory level reaches 3,300 units to avoid a stockout.

 

d) Explain any five ways to enhance customer service.                (05)

In today's competitive market, exceptional customer service is a key differentiator that can significantly impact a business's success.

1. Train Employees Thoroughly

One of the most crucial steps in enhancing customer service is providing comprehensive training for employees. This training should cover not only the technical aspects of their roles but also soft skills such as communication, empathy, and problem-solving.

  • Role-Playing Scenarios: Incorporate role-playing exercises to simulate various customer interactions. This helps employees practice their responses and develop confidence in handling different situations.
  • Continuous Learning: Encourage ongoing education through workshops, online courses, and seminars to keep staff updated on best practices and emerging trends in customer service.

2. Leverage Technology

Utilizing technology can streamline customer service processes and improve the overall customer experience.

  • Customer Relationship Management (CRM) Systems: Implement a CRM system to track customer interactions, preferences, and feedback. This allows for personalized service and quicker resolution of issues.
  • Chatbots and AI: Use chatbots for immediate responses to common inquiries. This can free up human agents to handle more complex issues, ensuring that customers receive timely assistance.

3. Foster Open Communication

Creating an environment of open communication between customers and the business is vital for enhancing customer service.

  • Feedback Channels: Establish multiple channels for customers to provide feedback, such as surveys, social media, and direct communication. Actively encourage customers to share their thoughts and experiences.
  • Responsive Communication: Ensure that responses to customer inquiries are prompt and informative. Acknowledge receipt of feedback and provide updates on any actions taken in response.

4. Personalize Customer Interactions

Personalization can significantly enhance the customer experience by making customers feel valued and understood.

  • Tailored Recommendations: Use data analytics to provide personalized product or service recommendations based on past purchases or preferences.
  • Special Offers: Create personalized promotions or discounts for loyal customers, recognizing their continued support and encouraging repeat business.

5. Empower Employees

Empowering employees to make decisions can lead to quicker resolutions and a more positive customer experience.

  • Decision-Making Authority: Allow employees to resolve customer issues without needing to escalate every situation. This not only speeds up the process but also instils confidence in staff.
  • Encourage Initiative: Foster a culture where employees feel comfortable taking the initiative to go above and beyond for customers. Recognize and reward those who demonstrate exceptional service.

 

Q.5) (a) Read the following case and answer the questions given below:

"Happy Kids" is a toy manufacturing company which is in the business for the past two decades. The manufacturing unit is situated in Mumbai, while its sales and marketing are spread over a large geographical area, especially in the major cities across the country. Over the years, a number of competitors have sprung in the field. Far from child's play, the company found that the toys sector is a tough business. Some of the problems faced by it are:

There is a massive sale during the festival seasons. If the company's product is delayed. the valuable market is missed.

"Fashion" or "cult" status products influence the market. Any wrong decision in this matter, means loss of sales and build-up of unwanted inventory

There are high marketing and promotional costs. If these programmes go out, the sales drop massively

Any misjudge of the market can also mean closing down of the company

The company has problems regarding stock holding at its distribution centers. This is mainly due to wrong inputs from feedbacks and improper surveys.

The company relies mainly on hired fleet of road transport. The services are not up to the mark in terms of delivery schedules, safety of goods from pilferage/theft, and mishandling of product.

Marketing strategies are far from adequate. They are not effective enough to counter the strategies adopted by the competitors.

You are called upon by the management of "Happy Kids" to head their logistics operations. You are required to study and guide the company with reference to following questions:

1) What strategies could "Happy Kids" implement to improve the reliability and safety of its transportation network, especially given its reliance on hired fleets for road transport?        (05)

Ans:

Given "Happy Kids" relies on hired fleets for road transport, improving delivery schedules, product safety, and handling is crucial. Here are five strategies:

1.     Partner with Reliable 3PL (Third-Party Logistics) Providers:

o    Collaborate with trusted logistics firms with a proven track record in timely delivery and cargo safety.

o    Example: Partnering with companies like DHL or Blue Dart for seasonal demand handling.

2.     Implement GPS Tracking & Real-Time Monitoring:

o    Install GPS systems on hired vehicles to track deliveries and identify bottlenecks.

o    Monitor on-time performance and pilferage risks in real time.

3.     Use Multi-Modal Transportation:

o    Incorporate railways or air transport during peak seasons for faster and safer delivery.

o    This strategy reduces the reliance solely on road transport.

4.     Contractual Service-Level Agreements (SLAs):

o    Establish SLAs with transport providers specifying delivery deadlines, damage protocols, and penalties for delays or losses.

o    Implement performance audits quarterly.

5.     Invest in Packaging and Handling Solutions:

o    Use tamper-proof and shock-resistant packaging to prevent mishandling.

o    Conduct training programs for drivers on product-specific handling procedures.

 

2) What role does collaboration with suppliers and distributors play in improving the responsiveness of "Happy Kids" to market trends and customer preferences?             (05)

Ans:

Collaboration with suppliers and distributors enhances market responsiveness by enabling better information flow, faster adjustments, and synchronized operations. Here’s how it helps "Happy Kids":

1.     Real-Time Data Sharing:

o    Implement integrated information systems for inventory visibility across the supply chain.

o    This helps in tracking market demand and preventing overstocking or understocking.

2.     Joint Demand Forecasting:

o    Collaborate on demand forecasts to predict festival surges and trending products.

o    Example: Work with distributors to track "fashion toys" and align production schedules accordingly.

3.     Flexible Inventory Management:

o    Implement a Vendor-Managed Inventory (VMI) system where distributors automatically replenish stock based on actual demand.

o    This reduces the bullwhip effect and improves stock accuracy.

4.     Streamlined Distribution Network:

o    Build regional hubs closer to key markets for faster delivery.

o    Engage in cross-docking to speed up shipments during peak seasons.

5.     Collaborative Promotions:

o    Coordinate with suppliers and distributors to develop joint marketing campaigns during high-demand periods.

o    Share advertising costs and real-time feedback for faster product adjustments.

 

3) As a Logistics Department Head what suggestions would you recommend to the toys manufacturing company to solve the above-mentioned problems?                    (05)

Ans:

As the Logistics Department Head, here are five key suggestions to address the company’s challenges:

1.     Adopt a Robust Supply Chain Management System:

o    Invest in ERP and TMS (Transport Management System) for end-to-end supply chain visibility.

o    Example: Use SAP S/4HANA or Oracle SCM for tracking inventory, market trends, and deliveries.

2.     Implement Just-In-Time (JIT) and Safety Stock Planning:

o    Use JIT for regular stock and maintain safety stock for peak seasons.

o    This ensures the company meets festival demand while minimizing excess inventory.

3.     Strengthen Market Research & Consumer Insights:

o    Conduct continuous market research to identify emerging toy trends.

o    Utilize big data analytics to analyze customer preferences and adjust production accordingly.

4.     Diversify Logistics Partnerships & Backup Plans:

o    Build a network of multiple logistics partners to prevent reliance on a single fleet.

o    Implement contingency plans (alternative transport methods like air freight) for time-sensitive deliveries.

5.     Optimize Marketing & Promotion Strategies:

o    Use digital marketing to engage customers in real time and promote new launches.

o    Partner with retailers and e-commerce platforms to boost seasonal visibility and offer exclusive deals.

 

OR

 

Q.5) b) Write short notes on (Any 3):                    (15)

1) RORO

RORO stands for Roll On/Roll Off. It means specially designed ships are used for carrying wheeled cargo such as cars, trucks, semi-trailer trucks, trailers, railroad cars which can be driven on and off the ship on their wheels through a vehicle platform. In India, smaller ships, barges are used for carrying two wheelers, light cargo, small trucks, etc. for crossing the river or creek where road transport is not available/feasible. Similarly Indian railways also provide RORO facility for transporting trucks on railway wagons.

Benefits of RORO Transport

1. RORO is most suitable method for transport of oversized vehicles which are unable to fit in standard containers.

2. RORO is the simplest, quick, one of the cheapest, efficient and convenient mode of transporting vehicles internationally.

3. Now, the RORO ships not only carry passenger cars but also trucks, boats, buses, motor homes, cranes, tractors and other huge and heavy machinery.

4 RORO car shipping is beneficial to both importers and exporters because (a) the cargo is "rolled on" from the loading port and (b) "rolled-off" the ship at the destination port.

5. The RORO shipping facility is available in specific areas except this limitation RORO shipping provides a very quick and affordable means of international transport of wheeled charge because it can apply to any vehicle of any size.

6. It saves shippers time on loading and unloading and can also be integrated with other transport means like containers.

 

2) Green Logistics

Ans: 

Green logistics refers to the process of minimizing the environmental impact of logistics activities, such as transportation, warehousing, and distribution. It aims to reduce carbon emissions, energy consumption, waste, and other negative environmental effects by adopting sustainable practices in supply chain management. The goal is to balance economic efficiency with environmental responsibility.

Components of Green Logistics:

1. Eco-Friendly Transportation: Using energy-efficient vehicles, alternative fuels, and optimizing delivery routes to reduce emissions.

2. Sustainable Packaging: Reducing the use of non-biodegradable materials, adopting reusable or recyclable packaging, and minimizing packaging waste.

3. Energy-Efficient Warehousing: Implementing energy-saving technologies such as LED lighting, renewable energy sources, and better insulation in warehouses.

4. Reverse Logistics: Managing the return, recycling, and disposal of products to reduce waste and promote product reuse.

5. Optimized Supply Chain: Streamlining processes to minimize unnecessary transportation and inventory handling, reducing fuel consumption and emissions.

Importance of Green Logistics:

Environmental Conservation: Reduces pollution, greenhouse gas emissions, and waste, helping combat climate change.

Cost Savings: Energy efficiency and optimized transportation lead to lower operational costs in the long term.

Regulatory Compliance: Many governments are implementing stricter environmental regulations, and green logistics helps businesses comply with these rules.

Enhanced Brand Image: Companies adopting green practices are often viewed more favorably by consumers, leading to improved brand reputation.

By incorporating green logistics into operations, businesses contribute to a more sustainable future while maintaining efficiency in their supply chains.

 

3) Drawbacks of Logistical Outsourcing

Logistical outsourcing has become a popular strategy for many businesses seeking to streamline operations and reduce costs. However, while it offers several advantages, there are also significant drawbacks that companies must consider.

Loss of Control

One of the most significant drawbacks of logistical outsourcing is the potential loss of control over the supply chain. When a company outsources its logistics, it entrusts critical functions to a third-party provider. This can lead to:

  • Quality Issues: The outsourced provider may not adhere to the same quality standards as the company, resulting in subpar service or products.
  • Inconsistent Branding: The way products are handled and delivered can affect customer perception. A lack of control can lead to inconsistencies that harm the brand image.
  • Operational Flexibility: Companies may find it challenging to adapt quickly to changes in demand or market conditions when relying on an external provider.

Dependency on Third-Party Providers

Outsourcing logistics creates a dependency on third-party providers, which can pose several risks:

  • Reliability Concerns: If the logistics provider fails to deliver on time or experiences operational issues, it can disrupt the entire supply chain.
  • Limited Responsiveness: Companies may find it difficult to respond quickly to customer needs or market changes due to reliance on an external partner.
  • Vendor Lock-In: Long-term contracts can lead to a situation where companies feel trapped with a provider that may not meet their evolving needs.

Communication Challenges

Effective communication is crucial in logistics, and outsourcing can complicate this aspect:

  • Misalignment of Goals: Different priorities between the company and the logistics provider can lead to misunderstandings and inefficiencies.
  • Cultural Differences: If the provider operates in a different region or country, cultural differences can impact communication and collaboration.
  • Information Sharing: Ensuring that both parties have access to the same information can be challenging, leading to delays and errors.

Hidden Costs

While outsourcing logistics can reduce operational costs, there are often hidden expenses that companies may overlook:

  • Transition Costs: The initial phase of outsourcing can involve significant costs related to training, integration, and setup.
  • Service Fees: Providers may charge additional fees for services that were previously handled in-house, such as storage, handling, or special requests.
  • Cost of Poor Performance: If the logistics provider fails to meet service levels, the company may incur costs related to customer dissatisfaction, returns, or lost sales.

Security Risks

Outsourcing logistics can expose companies to various security risks:

  • Data Vulnerability: Sharing sensitive information with third-party providers can increase the risk of data breaches or leaks.
  • Supply Chain Disruptions: External factors, such as natural disasters or political instability, can impact the logistics provider's ability to deliver goods, affecting the company's operations.
  • Compliance Issues: Companies must ensure that their logistics providers comply with relevant regulations, which can be challenging when outsourcing.

 

4) Mission based costing

Mission' in relation to logistics costing refers to a set of customer service goals to be achieved by the firm within a specific market, market or product context. Mission based costing is an example of integrated logistics and involves integration of large inputs from various activity centres like inventory, transport, warehousing, etc.) of the firm.

The basic purpose of mission-based costing is to identify those Coste that are generated because of specific logistics activities essentials to accomplish certain well-defined objective.

1. This diagram relates to a logistics company engaged in packing and moving services.

2. Mission A or Project A relates to shifting of home furniture from Delhi to Chennai.

3. Mission B or Project B relates to shifting of imported goods from Mumbai Port to Pune.

4. The company's logistics cost include packing material, labour transport and other incidental expenses.

5. The vertical total provides component wise cost like Packing cost= A + B

6. Horizontal cost i.e. Total cost = Packing + Labour cost + Transport+ Customer service = Total Mission cost

7. Revenue Potential = Cost of mission + Profit

8. Net Benefit = Revenue Realised - Cost of Mission

9. Analysis of the table shows:

(a) Packaging Cost = A + B

 = ₹ 7,000

(b) Labour Cost = A+B

= ₹ 4,000

(c) Transport Cost = A + B

= ₹ 25,000

(d) Customer Service Cost = A + B

= ₹ 3,000

Total Logistics Cost

= ₹ 39,000

Total Revenue (A + B) (40000 + 15000)

 = ₹ 55,000

Net Benefit (A + B) (10000 + 6000)

 = ₹ 16,000

10. Mission A Total Cost

= ₹30,000

11. Mission B Total Cost

= ₹ 9,000

 

₹ 39,000

                                             

So, mission-based costing is very useful to finding project/mission wise logistics cost and income.

Features/Characteristics of Mission Based Costing

1. Logistics mission is a set of customer service goals to be achieved by the firm with reference to a specific product/market like product development, advertising campaign.

2. Mission costing estimates the total cost of achieving the desired logistics objectives and the cost of various inputs involved in achieving these goals.

3. The mission costing concept is used to estimate cost likely to be incurred for accomplishing the objectives. For example, providing better customer service through call centres, baggage handling at airport, etc.

4. Mission based costing believes in improving performance by planning activities in advance.

5. Mission based costing deals with cost related to full mission instead or single and separate activities.

Benefits of Mission Based Costing

1. It is possible to identify the resource used on a particular project and revenue generated by its use.

2. It measures the input in terms of cost and output in revenue earned.

3. The input to output ratio ie. cost incurred and income generated is a better indicator to evaluate the efficiency of logistics process in terms of profitability.

4. This method highlights the benefits of service over cost considerations, "thereby, allows flexibility in services to optimise the benefits of the company.

5. Mission costing is associated with distribution centres and in particular transport sector.

6. It provides a budget estimate of expenses and revenue per project in advance.

7. It provides an idea about resources used in terms of cost for performing the mission and the output in terms of returns i.e. profit.

 

5) Golden Quadrilateral

Quadrilateral means having four sides or corners. It is a network of highways that connect four major cities - Delhi (North), Chennai (South Kolkata (East) and Mumbai (West), forming a quadrilateral shape, hence is called Golden Quadrilateral.

Characteristics of Golden Quadrilateral Highway Project

1. The main objective is to reduce the distance and travelling time between the four metropolitan cities of India. Thereby, reduce transport costs and ensure faster delivery of cargo.

2. The Golden Quadrilateral project was launched in 2001 and was operational in 2012. The project included construction of new highways, including renovation and extension of the existing highways to 4 to 6 lanes with total length of 5846 km.

3. The project provides transportation links between major cities from 13 states like Delhi, Jaipur, Udaipur, Ajmer, Ahmedabad, Mathura Varanasi, Mumbai, Pune, Bangalore, Vishakhapatnam, Chennai Bhubaneshwar and Kolkata.

4. It is the largest highway project of India and 5th longest highway project in the world.

Benefits of Golden Quadrilateral Project

1. Provides efficient road connectivity to 13 states and major cities o India.

2. Provides faster and better transportation mode for people and cargo.

3. The highway passes through major agricultural, industrial and cultural centres of India.

4. It also connects major centres of tourist attraction (like Jaipur and A and religious places like Mathura, Varanasi, Ajmer in Rajasthan

5. The highway provides facilities for integration of modes of transportation like railway and road because both the routes are parallel to each other.

6. Smaller towns around the major cities also have connectivity through major cities. This facility helps farmers from surround area to market their agriculture produce efficiently.





Post a Comment

0 Comments